Reply To: Exempt or RO decision

#9548
Kevin D
Participant

🙂

I’m assuming you’re referring to the “Edit” section (which, with hindsight wasn’t terribly well padded out. Although, there were mitigating reasons for it’s brevity…).

Hopefully :idea:, this will assist. There is a CD that states “contrived” can only be considered at the outset of the liability. That would, on the face of it, mean that if circumstances changed later, the “contrived” option couldn’t be considered. The context of my comment was that the CD would need to be challenged. For what it’s worth, I think it *may* be possible to argue against it.

Unfortunately, I’m a long way from my CDs at the moment, so can’t offer the reference at this time.

If it’s still not clear, by all means post – no offense will be taken.

Regards