Amount of overpayment to be repaid – help please!

Currently, there are 0 users and 1 guest visiting this topic.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • Author
  • #21363


    This could be really simple but once again I’m tying myself in knots…

    I have had two invoices for two different customers appealed by their landlord, not disputing that they should pay the overpayments back, but disputing the amounts. The two amounts overpaid are not the same as the landlord actually received for the periods in question, because we were making ongoing deductions for an earlier overpayment on both claims. I have tried to explain that the amount of the overpayment is calculated based upon the original entitlement because although part of it was going into another ‘pot’, that is the amount of HB technically paid.

    I am becoming less sure of my standing on this issue as the landlord could argue that the earlier overpayments being recovered from ongoing HB were not their debt and so not being repaid by them but actually by the tenants from their HB entitlement. In addition, the earlier overpayments were caused by changes to each tenant’s personal circumstances which the landlord couldn’t be expected to know about (although these were determined pre April 06….)

    On the one hand it seems logical that they pay back what’s been paid to them, regardless of where the money went (ie to the rent account or towards and exisiting debt) but then again……!

    Julian Hobson

    You need to look at the earlier overpayment decisions:

    1. If your decision was that the claimant was overpaid and that they should repay it then your Landlord has a very good point. When calculating the second OP your landlord can only be chased for the money they actually received. You need to chase the customer for the element that was offset against the original OP.

    2. If your decision was that the L/L was overpaid and that your recovery method was from direct payments then the Landlord would be liable for the whole of the second OP.


    ok thanks very much. Now wish me luck on finding those old notifications…

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.